IEEE 802.1 Ballot Tally
Index » Working Group Ballot of P802.1ar/D1.6
Tallied VotesOther Information
Approve [*]2 (18 %)Pass / Fail [***]Fail
Disapprove9 (82 %)Last Updated2008-07-16
Abstain [**]56 (84 %)Non-Voting Comments [****]0
Total67ParticipationClick to see a hard copy of the voters list. 67 / 169  Task Force 17
* Approve includes "Comments With Approve".
** Abstain includes "Comments With Abstain".
*** To "pass": Approval Percent >=75 % and Working Group Participation >= 50 %.
**** Non-voting comments are just "Comments".

Ballot Votes
ParticipantVoteDate
Maarten VissersWorking Group ParticipantAbstainMon Jun 9 11:44:57 2008
Nurit SprecherWorking Group ParticipantAbstainMon Jun 9 18:53:32 2008
Koichiro SetoWorking Group ParticipantAbstainMon Jun 9 19:02:38 2008
Jan BialkowskiWorking Group ParticipantAbstainMon Jun 9 19:18:45 2008
Muneyoshi SuzukiWorking Group ParticipantAbstainMon Jun 9 21:02:38 2008
Diego CrupnicoffWorking Group ParticipantAbstainTue Jun 10 00:20:49 2008
Zehavit AlonWorking Group ParticipantAbstainTue Jun 10 01:30:49 2008
Mace GaelTask Force ParticipantAbstainTue Jun 10 03:45:31 2008
Bonnamy Jean-Michel Rd-Resa-LanTask Force ParticipantAbstainTue Jun 10 03:46:50 2008
Rudolf BrandnerWorking Group ParticipantAbstainTue Jun 10 03:53:01 2008
David MartinWorking Group ParticipantAbstainTue Jun 10 09:33:15 2008
Craig GuntherWorking Group ParticipantAbstainTue Jun 10 11:15:26 2008
Dave OlsenTask Force ParticipantAbstainTue Jun 10 11:19:35 2008
Hiroshi OhtaWorking Group ParticipantAbstainWed Jun 11 06:51:03 2008
Tony JeffreeWorking Group ParticipantDisapproveWed Jun 11 08:48:06 2008
Menu MenuchehryTask Force ParticipantAbstainWed Jun 11 12:39:13 2008
Guenter RoeckWorking Group ParticipantAbstainWed Jun 11 16:37:25 2008
Moran RothWorking Group ParticipantAbstainWed Jun 11 16:49:02 2008
Ali SajassiWorking Group ParticipantAbstainWed Jun 11 17:11:01 2008
Francois TalletWorking Group ParticipantAbstainWed Jun 11 17:50:00 2008
George SwallowWorking Group ParticipantAbstainWed Jun 11 17:59:59 2008
Ben Mack-CraneWorking Group ParticipantAbstainThu Jun 12 12:32:29 2008
Dinesh MohanWorking Group ParticipantAbstainFri Jun 13 13:04:23 2008
Kevin StantonTask Force ParticipantAbstainFri Jun 13 13:34:46 2008
Mike KoWorking Group ParticipantAbstainFri Jun 13 14:52:32 2008
Satish SatheWorking Group ParticipantAbstainMon Jun 16 17:49:39 2008
Shlomo OvadiaWorking Group ParticipantAbstainMon Jun 16 18:54:43 2008
Ludwig WinkelWorking Group ParticipantAbstainTue Jun 17 05:22:20 2008
Joe PelissierWorking Group ParticipantAbstainTue Jun 17 17:05:22 2008
Insler Romain Rd-Resa-LanTask Force ParticipantAbstainWed Jun 18 04:09:01 2008
Panagiotis SaltsidisWorking Group ParticipantAbstainThu Jun 19 03:42:06 2008
Attila TakacsWorking Group ParticipantAbstainThu Jun 19 09:51:20 2008
John MessengerWorking Group ParticipantAbstainThu Jun 19 09:54:58 2008
Osama Aboul-MagdTask Force ParticipantAbstainThu Jun 19 12:01:25 2008
Don PannellWorking Group ParticipantAbstainThu Jun 19 13:04:44 2008
Don FedykWorking Group ParticipantAbstainThu Jun 19 13:19:54 2008
Anoop GhanwaniWorking Group ParticipantAbstainThu Jun 19 14:03:12 2008
Ken YoungWorking Group ParticipantAbstainThu Jun 19 18:57:42 2008
Janos FarkasWorking Group ParticipantAbstainFri Jun 20 08:50:25 2008
John TerryWorking Group ParticipantAbstainFri Jun 20 18:14:13 2008
Philippe KleinWorking Group ParticipantAbstainTue Jun 24 03:55:20 2008
Max PritikinWorking Group ParticipantDisapproveThu Jun 26 13:08:06 2008
John Nels FullerTask Force ParticipantDisapproveThu Jun 26 17:33:11 2008
Geoffrey M. GarnerTask Force ParticipantAbstainTue Jul 1 15:57:13 2008
Yan WangWorking Group ParticipantAbstainTue Jul 1 22:41:49 2008
Hal KeenWorking Group ParticipantAbstainSat Jul 5 15:47:39 2008
Bob SultanWorking Group ParticipantAbstainSat Jul 5 22:05:43 2008
Paul CongdonWorking Group ParticipantComments (With Approve)Mon Jul 7 03:33:34 2008
Claudio DesantiWorking Group ParticipantAbstainMon Jul 7 09:18:50 2008
Bruce KwanWorking Group ParticipantAbstainMon Jul 7 10:35:36 2008
Marco MascittoWorking Group ParticipantAbstainMon Jul 7 12:52:48 2008
Manoj WadekarWorking Group ParticipantAbstainMon Jul 7 12:54:44 2008
Norman FinnTask Force ParticipantAbstainMon Jul 7 13:15:39 2008
John SauerWorking Group ParticipantAbstainMon Jul 7 14:10:33 2008
Craig W. CarlsonWorking Group ParticipantAbstainMon Jul 7 16:56:15 2008
Henry (Chien-Hsien) WuTask Force ParticipantAbstainMon Jul 7 17:06:29 2008
Joseph SaloweyWorking Group ParticipantDisapproveTue Jul 8 01:43:18 2008
Raghu KondapalliWorking Group ParticipantAbstainTue Jul 8 09:43:35 2008
Stephen HaddockTask Force ParticipantAbstainTue Jul 8 12:34:54 2008
Franz-Josef GoetzTask Force ParticipantAbstainTue Jul 8 15:39:30 2008
Michael WrightTask Force ParticipantDisapproveTue Jul 8 18:27:30 2008
Robert RodenWorking Group ParticipantAbstainWed Jul 9 03:00:24 2008
Riccardo MartinottiWorking Group ParticipantAbstainWed Jul 9 03:09:28 2008
Alan McguireWorking Group ParticipantAbstainWed Jul 9 04:25:48 2008
Kari . LaihonenTask Force ParticipantDisapproveWed Jul 9 08:14:59 2008
Kevin NolishWorking Group ParticipantAbstainWed Jul 9 08:57:57 2008
Mitchell GusatTask Force ParticipantAbstainWed Jul 9 10:05:30 2008
Josef RoeseWorking Group ParticipantAbstainWed Jul 9 10:17:52 2008
David Elie-Dit-CosaqueWorking Group ParticipantAbstainWed Jul 9 11:08:06 2008
Dan RomascanuWorking Group ParticipantDisapproveWed Jul 9 13:49:12 2008
Caitlin BestlerWorking Group ParticipantAbstainWed Jul 9 14:28:12 2008
Ken GrewalWorking Group ParticipantDisapproveWed Jul 9 14:38:40 2008
Jessy V RouyerWorking Group ParticipantAbstainWed Jul 9 20:21:27 2008
Karen RandallWorking Group ParticipantDisapproveWed Jul 9 20:36:33 2008
Pat ThalerWorking Group ParticipantDisapproveWed Jul 9 22:45:20 2008
Brian WeisWorking Group ParticipantComments (With Approve)Thu Jul 10 00:05:19 2008
Keti KilcreaseWorking Group ParticipantDisapproveThu Jul 10 02:53:23 2008
Glenn ParsonsWorking Group ParticipantDisapproveThu Jul 10 09:59:21 2008
Paul BottorffWorking Group ParticipantAbstainThu Jul 10 20:18:58 2008
Eric GrayWorking Group ParticipantAbstainFri Jul 11 09:28:25 2008
Ken PattonWorking Group ParticipantAbstainFri Jul 11 10:35:56 2008
Bob FrazierWorking Group ParticipantAbstainMon Jul 14 01:27:36 2008
Yong KimTask Force ParticipantApproveMon Jul 14 12:25:38 2008
Asif HazarikaWorking Group ParticipantAbstainWed Jul 16 13:02:26 2008
Rob BoatrightClick to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
Jean-Michel BonnamyClick to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
Frank ChaoClick to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
Rao CherukuriClick to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
Taesik CheungClick to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
Alex ContaClick to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
Linda DunbarClick to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
Hesham ElbakouryClick to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
Felix Feifei FengClick to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
Norm FinnClick to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
John FullerClick to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
Geoffrey GarnerClick to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
Franz GoetzClick to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
Mitch GusatClick to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
Steve HaddockClick to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
Brian HassinkClick to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
Brian HausauerClick to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
Romain InslerClick to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
Paul Hongkyu JeongClick to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
Michael Johas TeenerClick to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
Prakash KashyapClick to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
Yongbum KimClick to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
Kari LaihonenClick to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
Yannick Le GoffClick to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
Gael MaceClick to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
Menucher MenucheryClick to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
David OlsenClick to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
Hayim PoratClick to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
Ananda RajagopalClick to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
Mick SeamanClick to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
Himanshu ShahClick to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
Ravi ShenoyClick to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
Kevin B StantonClick to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
Oliver ThorpClick to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
Fred TuckClick to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
Bert WijnenClick to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
Michael D. WrightClick to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
Chien-Hsien WuClick to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
The Closing Date Of This Ballot Is:Click to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
9th July 2008Click to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
The Pdf File Of P802.1ar/d1.6 Can Be Found At:Click to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
http://www.ieee802.org/1/files/private/ar-Drafts/d1/802-1ar-D1-6.pdfClick to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
A Version With Change Bars Is Here:Click to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
http://www.ieee802.org/1/files/private/ar-Drafts/d1/802-1ar-D1-6-Cb.pdfClick to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
Username: P8021Click to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
Password: Go_wildcatsClick to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
If You Have Any Difficulty Downloading Or Reading This File, Let Me Know.Click to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
As Is Normal With Such Ballots, Comments Should Specify Not Only WhatClick to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
Problems Have Been Identified With The Text, But Also What The CommenterClick to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
Proposes As A Solution.Click to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
Any Comments Accompanying The Ballot Must Be Presented Using EitherClick to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
Of The Templates To Be Found Here:Click to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
http://www.ieee802.org/1/files/private/commenting-Tool/myballot-Tools/Click to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
Comments Can Be Generated Using Excel Or An Equivalent SpreadsheetClick to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
Program That Will Read Xls Or Csv Format Files. Attach The ResultantClick to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
In FileClick to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
Returning Your Ballot FormClick to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
Your Ballot Must Be Returned To:Click to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
You Are Requested To Use (exactly!) The Appropriate Subject Line FromClick to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
The Following Set When Returning Your Ballot. Please Send Your BallotClick to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
With The Subject Line Explicitly Set, Rather Than Using The ReplyClick to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
Function In Your Mailer.Click to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
P802.1ar/d1.6 Ballot - ApproveClick to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
P802.1ar/d1.6 Ballot - Comments (with Approve)Click to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
P802.1ar/d1.6 Ballot - DisapproveClick to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
P802.1ar/d1.6 - Comments (with Abstain)Click to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
P802.1ar/d1.6 - AbstainClick to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
802.1 Chair.Click to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
Ballot Form Follows.....Click to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
Note: Email All Ballot Responses Only To: Stds-802-1-L@listserv.ieee.orgClick to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
P802.1ar/d1.6 Email BallotClick to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
To: Max PritikinClick to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
P802.1ar EditorClick to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
Subject: P802.1ar/d1.6 - Secure Device IdentifierClick to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
_____ I Approve (may Attach Non-Binding Comments Below)Click to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
_____ I Disapprove (must Attach Binding Comments Below)Click to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
_____ I Abstain For The Following Reasons (may Attach Non-BindingClick to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
Comments Below):Click to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
______ Lack Of TimeClick to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
______ Lack Of ExpertiseClick to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
______ Other: _______________________________________________Click to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
(telephone No.)Click to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
Include Comments Only As An Attachment, Using The Templates Identified Above.Click to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
  • [802.1 - 2876] P802.1ar/d1.6 - Abstain
    		• Click to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
    • from: Shlomo Ovadia
    		Click to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
  • [802.1 - 2824] P802.1ar/d1.6 - Abstain
    		• Click to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
    • from: Guenter Roeck
    		Click to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
  • [802.1 - 2796] P802.1ar/d1.6 - Abstain
    		• Click to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
    • from: Sprecher, Nurit (nsn - Il/israel - Minimd)
    		Click to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
  • [802.1 - 2794] P802.1ar/d1.6 - Abstain
    		• Click to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
    • from: Maarten Vissers
    		Click to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
  • prev By Date:
    		• Click to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
    [802.1 - 2794] P802.1ar/d1.6 - AbstainClick to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
  • next By Date:
    		• Click to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
    [802.1 - 2792] Working Group Ballot Of P802.1ar/d1.6 - Secure Device IdentifierClick to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
  • prev By Thread:
    		• Click to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
    [802.1 - 2797] P802.1ar/d1.6 - AbstainClick to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
  • next By Thread:
    		• Click to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
    [802.1 - 2794] P802.1ar/d1.6 - AbstainClick to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
  • date
    		• Click to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
  • thread
    		• Click to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
    "
    Download the Ballot Tally Application
    Web Tally V 2.0 #169; Copyright Ericsson 2019
    Comments and Questions