IEEE 802.1 Ballot Tally
Index » Working Group Ballot of P802.1Q-Rev/D1.0
Tallied VotesOther Information
Approve [*]21 (70 %)Pass / Fail [***]Fail
Disapprove9 (30 %)Last Updated2013-05-14
Abstain [**]15 (33 %)Non-Voting Comments [****]0
Total45ParticipationClick to see a hard copy of the voters list. 39 / 95  Task Force 63
* Approve includes "Comments With Approve".
** Abstain includes "Comments With Abstain".
*** To "pass": Approval Percent >=75 % and Working Group Participation >= 50 %.
**** Non-voting comments are just "Comments".

Ballot Votes
ParticipantVoteDate
Dennis VolpanoTask Force ParticipantDisapproveMon Jan 3 20:36:07 2005
Sam SambasivanTask Force ParticipantAbstainTue Jan 4 10:02:30 2005
Les BellTask Force ParticipantDisapproveWed Jan 5 09:59:41 2005
David B HarringtonTask Force ParticipantDisapproveWed Jan 5 11:08:56 2005
Jim BurnsTask Force ParticipantAbstainWed Jan 5 11:26:18 2005
Steve HaddockTask Force ParticipantComments (With Approve)Wed Jan 5 13:37:35 2005
Brandon BarryTask Force ParticipantApproveWed Jan 5 13:43:35 2005
Hesham ElbakouryTask Force ParticipantApproveWed Jan 5 15:40:40 2005
Dinesh MohanTask Force ParticipantApproveWed Jan 5 15:57:29 2005
Michael WrightTask Force ParticipantApproveWed Jan 5 17:32:31 2005
John ViegaTask Force ParticipantAbstainWed Jan 5 17:41:10 2005
Allyn RomanowTask Force ParticipantApproveWed Jan 5 20:27:51 2005
Loren LarsenTask Force ParticipantApproveThu Jan 6 02:03:06 2005
Don O'ConnorTask Force ParticipantApproveSat Jan 8 11:06:12 2005
Ken PattonTask Force ParticipantApproveMon Jan 10 10:50:31 2005
Anush ElangovanTask Force ParticipantApproveMon Jan 10 12:09:05 2005
Robert MoskowitzTask Force ParticipantAbstainMon Jan 10 12:26:57 2005
David Elie-Dit-CosaqueWorking Group ParticipantApproveThu Jan 13 00:45:29 2005
Ali SajassiWorking Group ParticipantApproveThu Jan 13 01:35:29 2005
Dolors SalaTask Force ParticipantAbstainThu Jan 13 04:12:35 2005
Weber KarlTask Force ParticipantApproveThu Jan 13 09:39:01 2005
David FratturaTask Force ParticipantApproveThu Jan 13 10:19:48 2005
Winkel LudwigTask Force ParticipantApproveThu Jan 13 10:38:10 2005
Arie HeerTask Force ParticipantApproveThu Jan 13 10:50:51 2005
Le Goff Yannick Rd-Resa-LanTask Force ParticipantApproveThu Jan 13 12:17:40 2005
Shahram DavariTask Force ParticipantApproveMon Feb 14 11:06:13 2005
Koichiro SetoWorking Group ParticipantApproveSat Feb 19 04:34:59 2005
Ran Ish-ShalomTask Force ParticipantApproveMon Feb 21 10:55:11 2005
James McintoshWorking Group ParticipantAbstainMon Jan 11 10:39:05 2010
Muneyoshi SuzukiWorking Group ParticipantDisapproveMon Jan 11 19:23:29 2010
Rudolf BrandnerWorking Group ParticipantAbstainFri Jan 15 07:09:47 2010
Tony JeffreeTask Force ParticipantComments (With Approve)Wed Feb 3 18:08:33 2010
John MorrisWorking Group ParticipantApproveMon Feb 8 11:07:21 2010
David MartinWorking Group ParticipantAbstainFri Feb 12 13:47:35 2010
Henry (Chien-Hsien) WuTask Force ParticipantAbstainSat Feb 13 14:27:10 2010
J . RoeseTask Force ParticipantApproveMon Feb 15 07:37:00 2010
Fedyk DonTask Force ParticipantComments (With Approve)Mon Feb 15 10:27:28 2010
Kari LaihonenWorking Group ParticipantApproveMon Feb 15 14:01:29 2010
Prakash KashyapWorking Group ParticipantApproveMon Feb 15 18:27:29 2010
Claudio DesantiWorking Group ParticipantApproveMon Feb 15 19:06:03 2010
Ben Mack-CraneWorking Group ParticipantDisapproveMon Feb 15 21:05:19 2010
Bruce KwanWorking Group ParticipantAbstainTue Feb 16 02:30:36 2010
Chuck HudsonTask Force ParticipantComments (With Approve)Tue Feb 16 09:01:46 2010
Zhemin DingWorking Group ParticipantComments (With Approve)Wed Feb 17 11:03:00 2010
Craig W. CarlsonTask Force ParticipantApproveFri Mar 5 13:49:32 2010
Kevin StantonWorking Group ParticipantAbstainFri Mar 5 19:25:28 2010
Asif Q HazarikaTask Force ParticipantAbstainSat Mar 6 12:03:51 2010
Mick SeamanTask Force ParticipantAbstainSun Mar 7 12:39:27 2010
Zehavit AlonTask Force ParticipantAbstainMon Mar 8 06:45:43 2010
Nurit SprecherWorking Group ParticipantAbstainMon Mar 8 09:01:42 2010
Menu MenuchehryTask Force ParticipantAbstainMon Mar 8 12:50:04 2010
Derek RohdeWorking Group ParticipantAbstainMon Mar 8 12:50:32 2010
Paul NikolichWorking Group ParticipantAbstainMon Mar 8 13:05:06 2010
John Nels FullerTask Force ParticipantAbstainMon Mar 8 14:43:12 2010
Matthew Xavier MoraTask Force ParticipantAbstainMon Mar 8 16:00:35 2010
Paul CongdonWorking Group ParticipantDisapproveMon Mar 8 17:33:03 2010
Franz-Josef GoetzTask Force ParticipantAbstainTue Mar 9 14:15:33 2010
Bob SultanTask Force ParticipantDisapproveTue Mar 9 22:02:57 2010
Bert WijnenWorking Group ParticipantApproveThu Mar 11 04:59:32 2010
Joe PelissierTask Force ParticipantComments (With Approve)Thu Mar 11 14:53:55 2010
John SauerWorking Group ParticipantApproveFri Mar 12 09:05:10 2010
Panagiotis SaltsidisWorking Group ParticipantDisapproveFri Mar 12 19:21:19 2010
Vinod Kumar MTask Force ParticipantDisapproveSat Mar 13 12:23:35 2010
Abhay KarandikarWorking Group ParticipantComments (With Approve)Mon Mar 15 09:06:50 2010
Bob FrazierTask Force ParticipantApproveMon Mar 15 10:02:47 2010
Joseph SaloweyWorking Group ParticipantAbstainMon Mar 15 10:18:13 2010
J LemonTask Force ParticipantAbstainMon Mar 15 10:33:48 2010
Diego CrupnicoffWorking Group ParticipantAbstainWed Apr 24 22:26:44 2013
Karen RandallWorking Group ParticipantAbstainFri Apr 26 11:50:09 2013
Markus JochimTask Force ParticipantAbstainThu May 2 16:53:58 2013
Paul BottorffWorking Group ParticipantDisapproveFri May 3 13:36:09 2013
Michael Johas TeenerTask Force ParticipantAbstainFri May 3 18:09:42 2013
Geoffrey M. GarnerTask Force ParticipantAbstainSat May 4 13:20:26 2013
Jeffrey LynchTask Force ParticipantApproveMon May 6 15:33:02 2013
Rodney CummingsTask Force ParticipantComments (With Approve)Mon May 6 16:14:37 2013
Hal KeenWorking Group ParticipantAbstainMon May 6 18:18:00 2013
Dave OlsenTask Force ParticipantAbstainMon May 6 18:59:52 2013
Hitoshi HayakawaTask Force ParticipantApproveMon May 6 22:48:32 2013
Craig GuntherWorking Group ParticipantComments (With Approve)Tue May 7 12:29:34 2013
R. BrandnerTask Force ParticipantAbstainTue May 7 15:47:29 2013
Johannes SpechtTask Force ParticipantAbstainTue May 7 16:03:28 2013
Richard SchellTask Force ParticipantAbstainTue May 7 18:00:23 2013
Pat ThalerTask Force ParticipantDisapproveTue May 7 23:39:24 2013
Philippe KleinWorking Group ParticipantApproveWed May 8 04:14:29 2013
Wilfried SteinerTask Force ParticipantAbstainWed May 8 07:37:58 2013
Ben MackcraneTask Force ParticipantDisapproveWed May 8 08:13:36 2013
Dan RomascanuWorking Group ParticipantAbstainWed May 8 08:28:25 2013
Mark GravelTask Force ParticipantAbstainWed May 8 09:03:47 2013
Oliver KleinebergTask Force ParticipantApproveWed May 8 09:39:26 2013
Christian BoigerTask Force ParticipantDisapproveWed May 8 11:16:27 2013
Anoop GhanwaniWorking Group ParticipantAbstainWed May 8 15:02:46 2013
Don PannellTask Force ParticipantAbstainWed May 8 19:14:50 2013
Weiying ChengWorking Group ParticipantApproveWed May 8 21:29:13 2013
Stephen HaddockWorking Group ParticipantDisapproveWed May 8 22:56:00 2013
Eric MultanenWorking Group ParticipantDisapproveThu May 9 02:05:46 2013
Irene AoTask Force ParticipantApproveThu May 9 03:52:11 2013
Janos FarkasWorking Group ParticipantDisapproveThu May 9 04:18:46 2013
Norman FinnWorking Group ParticipantComments (With Approve)Thu May 9 11:10:14 2013
Glenn ParsonsWorking Group ParticipantDisapproveThu May 9 13:37:18 2013
Yong KimTask Force ParticipantAbstainThu May 9 14:23:04 2013
Eric GrayWorking Group ParticipantAbstainThu May 9 15:37:32 2013
Jessy V RouyerTask Force ParticipantDisapproveTue May 14 10:43:52 2013
Siamack AyandehClick to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
Jan BialkowskiClick to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
Jean-Michel BonnamyClick to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
Craig CarlsonClick to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
Rao CherukuriClick to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
Jin-Seek ChoiClick to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
Don ConnorClick to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
Linda DunbarClick to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
Donald FedykClick to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
Robert FrazierClick to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
John FullerClick to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
Geoffrey GarnerClick to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
Franz GoetzClick to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
Karanvir GrewalClick to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
Mitch GusatClick to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
Asif HazarikaClick to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
Charles HudsonClick to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
Romain InslerClick to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
Anthony JeffreeClick to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
Pankaj JhaClick to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
Keti KilcreaseClick to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
Yongbum KimClick to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
Mike KoClick to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
Vinod KumarClick to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
Ashvin LakshmikanthaClick to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
John LemonClick to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
Marina LipshteynClick to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
Gael MaceClick to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
Alan McguireClick to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
Menucher MenucheryClick to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
John MessengerClick to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
Gabriel MontenegroClick to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
Matthew MoraClick to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
Kevin NolishClick to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
David OlsenClick to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
Donald PannellClick to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
Joseph PelissierClick to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
David PetersonClick to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
Hayim PoratClick to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
Max PritikinClick to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
Josef RoeseClick to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
Jessy RouyerClick to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
Jonathan SadlerClick to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
Satish SatheClick to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
Michael SeamanClick to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
Robert SultanClick to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
Michael TeenerClick to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
Patricia ThalerClick to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
Ao TingClick to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
Manoj WadekarClick to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
Yuehua WeiClick to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
Weis , BrianClick to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
Martin WhiteClick to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
Chien-Hsien WuClick to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
Ken YoungClick to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
Glen ZornClick to see a hard copy of the voters list.No VoteN/A
"