Index » Task Force Ballot of P802.1Qay/D3.0
| Tallied Votes | Other Information | ||
|---|---|---|---|
| Approve [*] | 12 (41 %) | Pass / Fail [***] | Fail |
| Disapprove | 17 (59 %) | Last Updated | 2008-05-13 |
| Abstain [**] | 43 (60 %) | Non-Voting Comments [****] | 0 |
| Total | 72 | Participation |  72 |
* Approve includes "Comments With Approve".
** Abstain includes "Comments With Abstain".
*** To "pass": Approval Percent >=75 % and Working Group Participation >= 50 %.
**** Non-voting comments are just "Comments".
Ballot Votes
| Participant | Vote | Date | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Guenter Roeck | | Abstain | Fri Apr 18 13:24:12 2008 |
| Brian Weis | | Abstain | Fri Apr 18 16:09:31 2008 |
| Joe Pelissier | | Abstain | Fri Apr 18 16:53:01 2008 |
| Brian Hassink | | Abstain | Fri Apr 18 17:02:32 2008 |
| Diego Crupnicoff | | Abstain | Sun Apr 20 23:39:19 2008 |
| Karen Randall | | Abstain | Mon Apr 21 07:24:12 2008 |
| Moran Roth | | Abstain | Wed Apr 23 03:34:37 2008 |
| Craig Gunther | | Abstain | Wed Apr 23 16:27:00 2008 |
| Geoffrey M. Garner | | Abstain | Wed Apr 23 16:31:02 2008 |
| Mike Ko | | Abstain | Thu Apr 24 01:46:28 2008 |
| Menu Menuchehry | | Abstain | Thu Apr 24 15:44:00 2008 |
| Franz-Josef Goetz | | Abstain | Fri Apr 25 08:54:10 2008 |
| Osama Aboul-Magd | | Abstain | Fri Apr 25 09:23:39 2008 |
| Shlomo Ovadia | | Abstain | Fri Apr 25 13:36:54 2008 |
| Michael Wright | | Abstain | Fri Apr 25 22:17:33 2008 |
| Keti Kilcrease | | Abstain | Sun Apr 27 00:16:14 2008 |
| Henry (Chien-Hsien) Wu | | Abstain | Mon Apr 28 02:27:48 2008 |
| Ludwig Winkel | | Abstain | Wed Apr 30 07:33:45 2008 |
| Muneyoshi Suzuki | | Disapprove | Wed Apr 30 21:41:32 2008 |
| Marco Mascitto | | Abstain | Thu May 1 10:46:48 2008 |
| David Martin | | Comments (With Approve) | Thu May 1 14:40:03 2008 |
| Linda Dunbar | | Disapprove | Thu May 1 18:33:38 2008 |
| Yong Kim | | Abstain | Thu May 1 19:46:12 2008 |
| Anoop Ghanwani | | Abstain | Thu May 1 21:46:27 2008 |
| John Sauer | | Approve | Fri May 2 15:29:25 2008 |
| Francois Tallet | | Abstain | Fri May 2 16:55:56 2008 |
| Deng Zhusheng | | Disapprove | Fri May 2 18:20:22 2008 |
| Paul Bottorff | | Abstain | Sat May 3 01:06:02 2008 |
| Hal Keen | | Abstain | Sat May 3 15:27:41 2008 |
| Robert Roden | | Disapprove | Sun May 4 09:30:15 2008 |
| Hesham Elbakoury | | Abstain | Sun May 4 22:09:28 2008 |
| Joseph Salowey | | Abstain | Mon May 5 00:01:35 2008 |
| Maarten Vissers | | Abstain | Mon May 5 03:27:29 2008 |
| Yannick1 . Legoff | | Abstain | Mon May 5 03:59:23 2008 |
| Yan Wang | | Abstain | Mon May 5 04:08:42 2008 |
| Kari . Laihonen | | Comments (With Approve) | Mon May 5 06:30:09 2008 |
| Mace Gael | | Abstain | Mon May 5 07:48:44 2008 |
| Bonnamy Jean-Michel Rd-Resa-Lan | | Abstain | Mon May 5 07:48:57 2008 |
| Hiroshi Ohta | | Disapprove | Mon May 5 08:23:10 2008 |
| Dan Romascanu | | Abstain | Mon May 5 08:33:51 2008 |
| Craig W. Carlson | | Abstain | Mon May 5 09:10:52 2008 |
| Tony Jeffree | | Abstain | Mon May 5 09:16:45 2008 |
| Rudolf Brandner | | Disapprove | Mon May 5 09:22:26 2008 |
| Kevin Nolish | | Disapprove | Mon May 5 09:51:19 2008 |
| Ken Grewal | | Abstain | Mon May 5 11:17:18 2008 |
| Steve Oliva | | Disapprove | Mon May 5 13:04:52 2008 |
| Bruce Kwan | | Abstain | Mon May 5 13:14:03 2008 |
| Eric Gray | | Disapprove | Mon May 5 13:36:15 2008 |
| Ken Young | | Disapprove | Mon May 5 14:08:57 2008 |
| Abhay Karandikar | | Disapprove | Mon May 5 14:14:14 2008 |
| Zhemin Ding | | Disapprove | Mon May 5 14:16:26 2008 |
| Raghu Kondapalli | | Abstain | Mon May 5 14:47:09 2008 |
| Claudio Desanti | | Approve | Mon May 5 16:50:31 2008 |
| Prakash Kashyap | | Comments (With Approve) | Mon May 5 18:01:37 2008 |
| Don Pannell | | Abstain | Mon May 5 18:39:16 2008 |
| David Elie-Dit-Cosaque | | Abstain | Mon May 5 18:39:53 2008 |
| Bob Sultan | | Disapprove | Mon May 5 19:48:28 2008 |
| Oliver Thorp | | Disapprove | Mon May 5 21:08:45 2008 |
| Don Fedyk | | Comments (With Approve) | Mon May 5 21:28:13 2008 |
| John Terry | | Abstain | Mon May 5 22:45:50 2008 |
| Mick Seaman | | Abstain | Mon May 5 22:49:21 2008 |
| Ben Mack-Crane | | Disapprove | Tue May 6 00:11:17 2008 |
| Jessy V Rouyer | | Disapprove | Tue May 6 00:49:21 2008 |
| Zehavit Alon | | Disapprove | Tue May 6 01:49:47 2008 |
| Stephen Haddock | | Abstain | Tue May 6 09:25:13 2008 |
| Janos Farkas | | Comments (With Approve) | Tue May 6 10:23:51 2008 |
| Riccardo Martinotti | | Comments (With Approve) | Tue May 6 12:16:48 2008 |
| Dinesh Mohan | | Comments (With Approve) | Tue May 6 14:57:43 2008 |
| Glenn Parsons | | Comments (With Approve) | Wed May 7 07:35:58 2008 |
| Pat Thaler | | Abstain | Thu May 8 16:34:33 2008 |
| Attila Takacs | | Approve | Fri May 9 03:00:33 2008 |
| Bob Frazier | | Approve | Tue May 13 10:54:49 2008 |