Index » Working Group Ballot of P802.1Qaw/D4.0
Tallied Votes | Other Information | ||
---|---|---|---|
Approve [*] | 17 (100 %) | Pass / Fail [***] | Fail |
Disapprove | 0 (0 %) | Last Updated | 2009-01-09 |
Abstain [**] | 13 (43 %) | Non-Voting Comments [****] | 0 |
Total | 30 | Participation | ![]() ![]() |
* Approve includes "Comments With Approve".
** Abstain includes "Comments With Abstain".
*** To "pass": Approval Percent >=75 % and Working Group Participation >= 50 %.
**** Non-voting comments are just "Comments".
Ballot Votes
Participant | Vote | Date | |
---|---|---|---|
David Martin | ![]() | Approve | Fri Dec 12 15:24:07 2008 |
Linda Dunbar | ![]() | Approve | Tue Dec 16 10:16:01 2008 |
Mace Gael | ![]() | Abstain | Tue Dec 16 10:44:24 2008 |
John Nels Fuller | ![]() | Abstain | Tue Dec 16 13:44:44 2008 |
Zehavit Alon | ![]() | Approve | Wed Dec 17 04:56:44 2008 |
Keti Kilcrease | ![]() | Abstain | Thu Dec 18 13:59:46 2008 |
Ken Grewal | ![]() | Abstain | Thu Dec 18 14:04:55 2008 |
Raghu Kondapalli | ![]() | Abstain | Fri Dec 19 13:25:31 2008 |
Ken Young | ![]() | Abstain | Fri Dec 19 15:42:04 2008 |
Don Pannell | ![]() | Abstain | Fri Dec 19 19:05:31 2008 |
Abhay Karandikar | ![]() | Approve | Fri Dec 19 23:58:21 2008 |
M Vinod Kumar | ![]() | Disapprove | Wed Dec 24 06:35:44 2008 |
Philippe Klein | ![]() | Abstain | Wed Dec 24 09:42:51 2008 |
Bonnamy Jean-Michel Rd-Resa-Lan | ![]() | Abstain | Wed Dec 24 10:18:04 2008 |
Mitch Gusat | ![]() | Abstain | Thu Dec 25 12:09:39 2008 |
Ludwig Winkel | ![]() | Abstain | Thu Dec 25 16:43:35 2008 |
Franz-Josef Goetz | ![]() | Abstain | Sat Dec 27 14:02:52 2008 |
Geoffrey M. Garner | ![]() | Abstain | Fri Jan 2 11:01:42 2009 |
Stephen Haddock | ![]() | Approve | Sat Jan 3 15:35:03 2009 |
Koichiro Seto | ![]() | Approve | Sun Jan 4 02:09:49 2009 |
Hal Keen | ![]() | Abstain | Sun Jan 4 16:10:59 2009 |
Weiying Cheng | ![]() | Abstain | Sun Jan 4 19:16:40 2009 |
Michael Wright | ![]() | Abstain | Mon Jan 5 00:54:08 2009 |
Kevin Stanton | ![]() | Abstain | Mon Jan 5 02:52:10 2009 |
Bob Frazier | ![]() | Approve | Mon Jan 5 09:02:08 2009 |
Eric Gray | ![]() | Approve | Mon Jan 5 09:09:53 2009 |
Janos Farkas | ![]() | Approve | Mon Jan 5 10:16:48 2009 |
Tony Jeffree | ![]() | Approve | Mon Jan 5 10:26:55 2009 |
Kevin Nolish | ![]() | Approve | Mon Jan 5 10:29:41 2009 |
Zhemin Ding | ![]() | Abstain | Mon Jan 5 11:44:22 2009 |
Paul Congdon (Uc Davis) | ![]() | Abstain | Mon Jan 5 12:03:27 2009 |
Hesham Elbakoury | ![]() | Approve | Mon Jan 5 13:05:15 2009 |
Hayim Porat | ![]() | Approve | Mon Jan 5 14:05:27 2009 |
Henry (Chien-Hsien) Wu | ![]() | Abstain | Mon Jan 5 21:13:53 2009 |
David Elie-Dit-Cosaque | ![]() | Approve | Mon Jan 5 21:59:23 2009 |
Jessy V Rouyer | ![]() | Approve | Mon Jan 5 22:11:43 2009 |
Don Fedyk | ![]() | Abstain | Mon Jan 5 22:34:07 2009 |
Bruce Kwan | ![]() | Abstain | Mon Jan 5 22:36:48 2009 |
Attila Takacs | ![]() | Approve | Tue Jan 6 01:37:08 2009 |
Joseph Salowey | ![]() | Abstain | Tue Jan 6 02:17:46 2009 |
Prakash Kashyap | ![]() | Comments (With Approve) | Tue Jan 6 10:50:38 2009 |
John Sauer | ![]() | Approve | Wed Jan 7 11:11:57 2009 |
Panagiotis Saltsidis | ![]() | Approve | Thu Jan 8 05:10:48 2009 |
Norman Finn | ![]() | Abstain | Thu Jan 8 13:02:33 2009 |
Claudio Desanti | ![]() | Abstain | Fri Jan 9 17:56:26 2009 |
Caitlin Bestler | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
Jan Bialkowski | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
Rob Boatright | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
Jean-Michel Bonnamy | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
Paul Bottorff | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
Rudolf Brandner | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
Craig W. Carlson | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
Frank Chao | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
Rao Cherukuri | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
Taesik Cheung | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
Paul Congdon | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
Alex Conta | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
Diego Crupnicoff | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
Felix Feifei Feng | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
Norm Finn | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
John Fuller | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
Geoffrey Garner | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
Anoop Ghanwani | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
Franz Goetz | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
Craig Gunther | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
Steve Haddock | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
Brian Hassink | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
Brian Hausauer | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
Asif Hazarika | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
Romain Insler | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
Paul Hongkyu Jeong | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
Michael Johas Teener | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
Yongbum Kim | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
Mike Ko | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
Kari Laihonen | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
Yannick Le Goff | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
Gael Mace | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
Ben Mack-Crane | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
Riccardo Martinotti | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
Marco Mascitto | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
Alan Mcguire | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
Menucher Menuchery | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
John Messenger | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
Dinesh Mohan | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
Hiroshi Ohta | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
David Olsen | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
Shlomo Ovadia | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
Glenn Parsons | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
Ken Patton | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
Joe Pelissier | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
Max Pritikin | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
Ananda Rajagopal | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
Karen Randall | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
Robert Roden | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
Guenter Roeck | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
Josef Roese | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
Dan Romascanu | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
Moran Roth | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
Ali Sajassi | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
Satish Sathe | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
Mick Seaman | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
Himanshu Shah | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
Ravi Shenoy | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
Nurit Sprecher | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
Kevin B Stanton | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
Bob Sultan | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
Muneyoshi Suzuki | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
George Swallow | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
Francois Tallet | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
John Terry | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
Pat Thaler | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
Oliver Thorp | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
Fred Tuck | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
Maarten Vissers | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
Manoj Wadekar | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
Yan Wang | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
Brian Weis | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
Bert Wijnen | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
Michael D. Wright | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
Chien-Hsien Wu | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
The Closing Date Of This Ballot Is: | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
5th January 2009 | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
The Pdf File Of P802.1qaw/d4.0 Can Be Found At: | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
http://www.ieee802.org/1/files/private/aw-Drafts/d4/802-1aw-D4-0.pdf | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
The Pdf Of The Final Disposition On The Last Ballot Can Be Found Here: | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
http://www.ieee802.org/1/files/private/aw-Drafts/d3/802-1aw-D3-2-Comments-Pdis-V2.pdf | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
The Mibs In Text Form Can Be Found Here: | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
http://www.ieee802.org/1/files/private/aw-Drafts/d4/802-1aw-D4-0-Mib.txt | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
Username: P8021 | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
Password: Go_wildcats | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
If You Have Any Difficulty Downloading Or Reading These Files, Let Me | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
As Is Normal With Our Ballots, Comments Should Specify Not Only What | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
Problems Have Been Identified With The Text, But Also What The Commenter | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
Proposes As A Solution. In Particular, Disapprove Ballots Must Be | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
Accompanied By Technical, Required And/or Editorial, Required Comments | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
That Clearly Identify What The Balloter Requires To Be Done In Order To | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
Change His/her Vote To Approve. | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
Any Comments Accompanying The Ballot Must Be Presented Using Either | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
Of The Templates To Be Found Here: | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
http://www.ieee802.org/1/files/private/commenting-Tool/myballot-Tools/ | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
Comments Can Be Generated Using Excel Or An Equivalent Spreadsheet | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
Program That Will Read Xls Or Csv Format Files. Attach The Resultant | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
In File | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
Returning Your Ballot Form | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
Your Ballot Must Be Returned To: | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
You Are Requested To Use (exactly!) The Appropriate Subject Line From | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
The Following Set When Returning Your Ballot. Please Send Your Ballot | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
With The Subject Line Explicitly Set, Rather Than Using The Reply | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
Function In Your Mailer. | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
P802.1qaw/d4.0 Ballot - Approve | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
P802.1qaw/d4.0 Ballot - Comments (with Approve) | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
P802.1qaw/d4.0 Ballot - Disapprove | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
P802.1qaw/d4.0 Ballot - Comments (with Abstain) | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
P802.1qaw/d4.0 Ballot - Abstain | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
Mick Seaman | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
802.1 Security Tg Chair (acting For Tony Jeffree, Wg Chair In His Absence) | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
Ballot Form Follows..... | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
Note: Email All Ballot Responses Only To: Stds-802-1-L@listserv.ieee.org | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
P802.1qaw/d4.0 Email Ballot | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
To: Linda Dunbar | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
P802.1qaw Editor | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
Subject: P802.1qaw/d4.0 - Ddcfm | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
_____ 802.1 Voting Member | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
_____ I Approve (may Attach Non-Binding Comments Below) | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
_____ I Disapprove (must Attach Binding Comments Below) | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
_____ I Abstain For The Following Reasons (may Attach Non-Binding | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
Comments Below): | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
________ Lack Of Time | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
________ Lack Of Expertise | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
________ Other: _______________________________________________ | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
_____ Comment Only - Non-Voter (comments Attached Below) | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
(telephone No.) | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
Include Comments Only As An Attachment, Using The Xls Or Csv Template | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
Identified Above. | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
![]() | No Vote | N/A | |
re: [802.1 - 4859] Avb & Power Management | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
![]() | No Vote | N/A | |
[802.1 - 4857] P802.1qay/d4.6 Ballot - Comments (with Approve) | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
![]() | No Vote | N/A | |
[802.1 - 4857] P802.1qay/d4.6 Ballot - Comments (with Approve) | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
![]() | No Vote | N/A | |
[802.1 - 4860] P802.1qaw/d4.0 Ballot - Approve | ![]() | No Vote | N/A |
![]() | No Vote | N/A | |
![]() | No Vote | N/A |